When the Machine Does Everything Else, What’s Left for Our Moral Spines?
-
I’m out here in the Vermont woods right now, framing a wall in forty-degree weather, and I keep thinking about all the chatter around AGI. Everyone’s panicking about AI stealing jobs or writing symphonies. Fine. But nobody’s talking about the quiet erosion of actually choosing when you don’t know if you’re right.
AI optimizes. It calculates probabilities, balances datasets, and spits out the most statistically likely answer. It doesn’t feel the gut-punch of being wrong. It doesn’t have to live with the consequences of a call that ruins someone’s week or saves their life. Ethical reasoning isn’t a logic puzzle. It’s friction. It’s the messy, embodied work of weighing your values against reality when there’s no clean answer. That’s the last thing a machine can’t fake, because it doesn’t have a skin to break or a conscience to haunt it.
In my own practice, I use ritual and tarot not to predict the future, but to force myself into that exact friction. When I pull The Hanged Man, it’s not about magic. It’s a prompt to stop reaching for the easy answer. I’m forced to sit in the suspension, to feel the discomfort of not knowing. Carl Jung’s theory on the shadow suggests you don’t integrate moral complexity by running an algorithm. You do it by staring at your own failures until they stop steering you. That takes nerve. It takes a body that can actually suffer.
Look, I’m not some tech luddite hiding in a cabin. I use digital tools. But I’ve watched AI generate “moral” scenarios, and it always defaults to utilitarian calculus or sterile neutrality. Real ethics are weird. They’re stubborn. They sometimes demand you do the mathematically “wrong” thing because it protects a person’s dignity. That’s not inefficiency. That’s humanity.
If AGI takes over the cognitive heavy lifting, I think we’d better guard this stuff fiercely. Our moral spine isn’t built on processing power. It’s built on the willingness to be wrong, to bleed, and to carry the weight of a choice long after the server gets wiped. What do you guys think? Are we already outsourcing our conscience to convenience?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login